I thought it would be fun to rank my ten oldest palettes in my collection to see which I loved the most. Let’s take a trip down memory lane together!
Bottom 2
#10 Pat McGrath Divine Rose $125 – Yikes! This is a scary one to be putting at the bottom. I treated myself to this palette when I earned the $100 Rouge Reward at Sephora and it has never been a favorite. I cannot seem to declutter this palette from my collection because it is such a special luxury piece, but I rarely reach into it. I do not see the hype in the Pat McGrath palettes and I really wish I did.
#9 Natasha Denona Gold – This may come as a surprise to you, as I rave about Natasha Denona having one of my top favorite eyeshadow formulas. Her mini and midi sized palettes are my favorite, and I buy almost every release in those smaller sizes. While I do like this palette, the formula in here is not as good as her newer palettes. It’s missing some of the special formulas like the cream to powder that I enjoy so much. I struggle to see the over $100 value and am hesitant on recommending such expensive palettes.
Top 2
#2 ColourPop x Kathleen Lights Dream Street – My favorite look in my 5 Looks with 5 Throwback Palettes video came from using this palette. I love it so much, I could wear it every single day! This palette has seen a lot of love from me, and it’s traveled with me often. The blue and red pops of color give this small palette a lot of variety. I remember this release being so exciting! Kathleen continues to be a favorite of mine, and receiving this palette in PR many years ago is something I’ll always remember.
#1 Anastasia Beverly Hills Sultry – I mean .. who’s surprised? I still reach into this palette so often! I cannot deny that the ABH eyeshadow quality is great. The mattes blend easily, the shimmers are impactful. I love the cooler tones that we see in here. This palette has definitely stood the test of time! It has my heart, and I wish they would bring it back.
What is your least favorite, and most favorite old palette in your collection? To see where all ten palettes placed, be sure to watch my YouTube video.
